Preferable to Confinement

“How long has it been, now?”

“Two hours, forty-seven minutes,” answered Harry Kim from his post at Operations. Kathryn bit back a sigh. It was the third time she’d asked the question, and it was becoming harder and harder to keep the worry and frustration at bay.

“Any sign of their commbadges?” she continued, hoping her voice wouldn’t betray her.

“No, ma’am.”

They had known the commbadge signals wouldn’t penetrate through the selonite on the surface—that was part of what killed Randleman—but Chakotay had maintained the hourly check-in schedule until his last call. She’d initially argued with him about it, but he’d successfully talked her into letting them investigate deeper into the chambers beneath the surface.

We’ll try to keep up at least two-hour intervals, or at least as close to that as possible, he’d said as he’d signed off.

All right, she’d finally allowed. Just don’t make it much longer than that.

She had almost been able to see the smirk on his face. Aye-aye, Captain.

“Captain!” called Harry suddenly, startling her out of her thoughts. “I have their commbadges!”

Two weeks ago, she would have sprung up from the chair to join him at his console. Now, she turned to face him. She was learning to live within her limits.

“Is that confirmed?” she asked.

“Yes, Captain,” said Rollins from Tactical. “The signals are weak, but it is definitely them.” He frowned at one of the readings. “You’d think they’d be trying to hail us since they’re past due.”

“Belay the chatter and hail them!”

Rollins tried for several minutes before shaking his head. “I’m sorry, ma’am. No response, and I’ve lost the signals again.”

Tom Paris spun around in his chair. “You’re going down there?”

“Yes.”

“Captain, I don’t think—”

“Objection noted. You’ll be in command.”

“Captain.” He was on his feet now. “May I speak with you in the Ready Room?”

“No time, Tom.” She didn’t want to hear it anyway, even if it had taken her longer than him to get to her feet.

“Ma’am.” He drew himself up to full attention. “I think I have to insist.”

His stance was polite, but his expression was determined to the point of being stubborn. “All right. Five minutes.”

She made a point of turning to speak as soon as the doors slid shut, wanting to get control of the conversation from the start. “I know what you’re going to say, Tom, but I’m not an invalid.”

“I’m not suggesting you are,” he answered. “It’s just that—”

“Chakotay spoke to you before he left, didn’t he? And made you agree not to let me do anything…stupid, right?”

The trapped look in his eyes told her the answer.

“It’s all right,” she told him now. “I can walk on my own now.”

He nodded but then took a breath. “Seven said there’s some pretty lousy footing down there, Captain, and you’re still having balance problems. Not to mention that you’re staying off your feet more than you used to.”

So people had noticed that. After a moment, she went to a corner and picked up the brand-new cane that was resting there. She’d started out using a generic one that the Doctor had replicated, but Chakotay had surprised her this morning with this one. It was designed to emulate carved wood, and had a bright metal tip.

“Will this make you feel better?” she asked her helmsman.

He nodded. “I’m sorry. I know it’s a breach of protocol to object.”

“You did it because you were told to, and not without reason. I could be a liability.” That was still harder to admit than she was willing to let show yet. Unfortunately, it was also true. “I think we’ll be fine this time, though. The commbadges would have registered differently if they were hurt or dead.”

“I know,” he said, “and I hope so. Captain, please be careful. I’ll never hear the end of it if something happens to you.”

At that, she smiled. “That I can do. I’ll be okay. I promise.” And she did, to both of them.


He woke to pain in his back and legs, giving him a sickening sense of sympathy for his captain. But a minute later, he realized he could move and feel just fine. He was simply bruised and sore; he must have been carelessly tossed onto whatever solid surface lay beneath him.

Chakotay sat up. “Tuvok? Seven? Neelix?”

“Here, Commander,” said Seven, who was crouching down next to him. Neelix stood behind her, and Tuvok was across the room, examining a wall that was different from the others. It glittered, as though it were made of crystal.

“Where are we?” he asked.

“It appears to be a cell of some sort,” she answered. She indicated a few pieces of furniture, a fountain of water, and a table that held something which might be food. There was also a walled-off alcove near the back, which suggested toilet facilities. “It is, however, not an uncomfortable place for confinement.”

“It’s still confinement,” he said as he pushed to his feet. She was right, though; it didn’t look like a prison cell. It seemed more like a holding area instead.

After stretching and soothing his still-complaining muscles, he joined Tuvok at the far wall. The Vulcan was examining a series of openings that were far too small to allow escape, but did permit a view into the chamber beyond the cell. “What have you figured out?”

“Very little. I only woke up a few minutes before you did. Clearly, though, this area is meant as some manner of restraint.”

“They meant to keep us from making another attempt to get into the deeper chambers,” he replied, thinking out loud. “That lends credence to the idea of a security room or holding area, versus a prison cell.”

Neelix joined them. “There doesn’t seem to be any sort of restraining field,” he reported. “It’s all mechanical, made of metal and stone. Except for this odd quartz-like stuff,” he concluded as he patted the wall where they stood.

“The consistency is closer to that of diamonds,” said Seven. “Quartz is not as rigid as this material.”

Quartz and diamonds. Something nibbled at the back of Chakotay’s mind, but he pushed it aside for the moment. This wasn’t the time for scientific speculation. “Do we know what it actually is made out of?

“No,” said Seven, regret in her voice. “Our tricorders have been taken from us.”

So had their phasers, but their commbadges were still there. He reached up to try his.

“They are not effective,” said Tuvok. “Based on the view outside this wall. I believe we’re still well below the surface.”

“And the selonite deposits. Great.” He looked around. “Options?”

“For breaking through something as hard as diamond?” asked Neelix.

“Someone put us in here,” said Chakotay, “and transporters don’t work any better through selonite than our commbadges. That means they had to have come in here and then left. And that means there’s a way out.”


Chakotay’s tricorder was lying on the floor of the security room. Moving carefully and using the cane for balance, Kathryn picked it up. It was still open and active, suggesting it had been dropped.

“Captain?” asked Harry from across the room. “The power generators are online, and this console is energized, but I can’t tell if there was any activity.”

“Be careful,” she told him, opening the tricorder. She suppressed the urge to cough. The air in this room was more than a bit stale, and it had an odd smell. “That could have been whatever happened to them. Chakotay wouldn’t have willingly left this behind.”

It seemed, based on its position, that Chakotay had dropped the tricorder while he was working on a translation of the odd writing on one of the room’s walls. The Universal Translator had kept running in his absence. It wasn’t a full translation, but it had unscrambled enough words to provide some rough estimates.

Do not engage the—, it said, indicating a word that was still not translated. Instead, request that the—run the last—file. You must do this quickly, before the—.

She paced toward the console in the middle of the room, wondering what its purpose might have been. Harry was trying various command combinations.

“Be careful,” she told him. “The words over there look like a warning.”

He nodded without looking up from his task. She slowly made her way around the room, looking for more evidence of the away team’s fate and discovering a phaser in the corner. Its power cell had been completely drained via some artificial means.

This vanished civilization had definitely progressed beyond the primitive level if they could recognize the difference between a scientific instrument and a weapon, and only de-energize one of them. She wondered if they’d gotten as far as space flight.

“Welcome to this sanctuary,” said a new voice behind her. Leaning on the cane to keep her balance, Kathryn turned around to see the image of a humanoid avian behind her. It flickered a little, suggesting holographic projection.

“You are overdue,” it continued, “but not too late. Remain where you are. After I have scanned you to confirm your identities, we will proceed to the lower chambers. Please forgive the inconvenience.”

Do not engage, the warning had stated. “Wait,” she said quickly. “We don’t want to go to the lower chambers.”

The projection paused. “Please state your purpose, then.”

She glanced at the tricorder again. “Run the last file.”

“I need clarification. Last historical recording? Last residency record? Something else?” It was couched in normal-sounding speech, but the computer-like nature of the request was clear.

She thought for a moment, noticing absently that Harry had eased around to stand behind her. “What’s the last file recorded, of any type?”

The hologram abruptly vanished.

“Wait!” Kathryn began scanning again. What would be the right command to re-start the projection?

Another image flickered to life. It appeared to be the same being, but it was now stooped and the rich, feathered crest on its head had become sparse. When it looked up, she could see that the being’s eyes had glazed over, the same way a human’s might due to age.

“My name,” it said, “is Numinda Claari. You’ve reached the last sanctuary of my people, and you’ve found me—the last of our kind to survive.”


Seven of Nine frowned as she knelt next to the crystalline wall. Using the hand that still had metallic implants from her time spent as a Borg, she cautiously tapped it. It rang slightly, with a higher tone than would be expected for solid rock, duranium, or a similar non-crystalline substance.

Rising to her feet, she tapped again at a higher point on the wall. The pitch of the tone became even higher, but the crystals’ echoing effect was still quite obvious. She ran her flesh-covered fingers between the two places she’d tapped. There was no discernible change in the substance’s feel.”

“Seven?” It was Commander Chakotay.

“This method of investigation is…” she hesitated. “Crude, but not ineffective. There is a difference in the nature of the crystal as it gets further from the floor.”

“Difference.”

She tapped the two places again.

He shook his head. “I don’t hear anything.”

“There’s a forty megahertz increase in the pitch.”

“Only forty? No wonder I didn’t hear it; I don’t have perfect pitch. But it could just be a natural variation.”

She reached above her head to tap even higher on the wall. This time, he reacted; he could hear that difference, then. He leaned back on his heels, studying the wall. “Hmm. Do you think the crystal is weaker toward the top, too?”

“I am unable to determine the specifics,” she answered. “There is some sort of change in the internal structure, but I do not have enough evidence to speculate.”

“Still.” He kept considering the wall, and she wondered if perhaps he could see something she couldn’t. Then he shook his head, and she realized he hadn’t been looking at the wall at all. It wasn’t always easy to tell when other humans were and weren’t paying attention. Then he removed his commbadge.

She frowned again. “Commander, we have already established that those are non-functional.”

“They’re functioning,” he corrected her. “They’re just not reaching Voyager.” Now he was prying off the cover. “It occurs to me that if there are different structures in the crystal, it might respond to harmonics. Hand me your badge.”

She complied, and he began disassembling that one too. “We should be able to cross-circuit these and create some sort of a vibration.”

Tuvok joined them. “An interesting theory.”

“It’s the best one I have at the moment.”

Seven thought about this and then started rolling up her sleeve. “We will need a means of controlling the harmonics. One of my implants may contain a circuit that could be used.”

“Won’t that hurt you? I thought the Doctor had already removed everything he could.”

“The damage will be repairable,” she said, thinking that it was also preferable to continued confinement. While the chamber was comfortable, the temperature was lower than optimal, particularly for her. And while the ship was surely looking for them by now, there was no way to tell if a rescue party would be able to penetrate the caverns down to this level.

Escape was up to them.


“Who are—” Kathryn began.

The image of the alien didn’t respond or even acknowledge. “Our astronomers,” it began, “identified the star-storm in my grandparents’ time, though it was not widely accepted until I myself began final studies. The life of a star seems eternal when compared with ours, after all. How, then, could one die?”

“A nova,” said Kathryn softly. “That’s the end of a star’s life cycle.” Harry was busy recording, so she used Chakotay’s tricorder to begin scanning through the data they had on local star systems.

“And if stars are really just collections of burning gases, how could the death of a star not our sun have an impact on us? Wouldn’t the star simply burn itself out, the same way as a fire?”

Kathryn had done her doctoral research on a type of stellar remnant, so she knew the answer: no. Based on Numinda Claari’s stance, she knew it too. Novae could cause upheavals for a long way before their shock waves dissipated.

The tricorder in her hands beeped softly. It had found a match. Three million years ago, there had been a nova about seventy light years away.

“By the time I finished my adult’s training,” the image continued, “the effects had become discernible. Our skies danced with color, even during the day, and compasses had become unreliable. It was about this time that our people began to fragment.

“One faction—mine—realized it was already too late to save our entire population, and would have been even had we begun work in our grandparents’ time. But it wasn’t too late, we thought, to save our civilization. We began quietly assembling our entire knowledge and preparing these sanctuaries. We knew we had to work in secret, because there would eventually come a time when we, as a people, would be faced with the decisions about who would survive and who would not.”

The hologram paused for a long moment, and its originator’s eyes briefly became distant before she continued. “It was inevitable, of course, that word would eventually get out. Our aim was simply to keep the secret until all our knowledge had been collected. When the news broke, I’m not sure who was more surprised: our society as a whole, or those of us who’d already begun preparations.

“Because not everyone wanted a place here.”

Out of the corner of her eye, Kathryn could see that Harry was just as captivated as she was.

“Some, of course, maintained their denial of the situation even as our world itself began to turn on us. Others speculated that the Sanctuary movement, as we had come to be called, would simply be a gathering of the elite. They also questioned whether life in the caves below the surface would be a life worth living.

“It was a difficult time, and differences of opinion ran high. We split and fractured, friend against friend, parent against child, even brother against sister.” The image paused again as she took a sharp breath, and the speaker’s voice dropped to a whisper of pain. “Even brother against sister.

“My own brother, Numinda Saan, believed that the Sanctuary movement was engaging in a pointless and futile exercise. He insisted that our time had simply come and that acceptance was the better path. This was our fate. Of course I disagreed.

“But I also digress.” Claari’s voice became steadier. “Needless to say, our world dissolved into near-madness, and extensive security became necessary within the sanctuaries. But we accomplished our goal: a massive collection of knowledge, and preservation of a sufficient number of people to ensure the genetic diversity we would need to rebuild once the star-storm had passed.

“We didn’t understand, then, that the effects of the star-storm would render our world nearly uninhabitable. Nor did we realize that the protection afforded by the rock layers was insufficient. The radiation didn’t kill those in the sanctuaries right away, the way it did on the surface. Instead, all of the females were rendered infertile. We hadn’t escaped our fate. We had only prolonged it.”

Claari’s crest was completely flat by now.

“In a bitter twist, I reached my goal. I was the foremost proponent of the Sanctuary movement, and I’ve survived until the end of my normal life expectancy. I am now old, and I will not live much longer. But I have lived long enough to see and recognize the end of my people, and to realize that my brother was right. It might have been fate, or a terrible coincidence, but acceptance of our demise was a far healthier reaction than a fight against the limits the universe imposed.

“That,” her image concluded, “only results in bitterness and regret.”

The image flickered and died, and Kathryn realized she had tears in her eyes. She blinked them away before anyone else could see. “Lieutenant Kim, can you access the database?”

“I couldn’t before. There were too many safeguards.” He tried the console. “They’re gone now, Captain.”

Neither of them, of course, were surprised.


“Ready?” asked Neelix.

“As ready as I think I’ll be,” answered Chakotay. “Tuvok? Seven?”

“Preparations are complete,” answered Seven.

Tuvok nodded. “There is nothing left now but to make the attempt.”

Chakotay bent over their makeshift radio and touched a slender wire to two points, completing an electrical circuit. With a jerk, it began to hum. Neelix helped him carry it over to the weakest part of the wall, an area near one of the openings. They were careful not to let the circuit inadvertently be reopened.

As they’d hoped, the edge of the wall opening began to vibrate fractionally. Seven placed two fingers against it. “It is reacting in sync with the harmonic frequency.”

“Let’s hope it’s the right frequency,” Chakotay answered.

The hum continued, with no visible effects, for some time. Chakotay felt his hands beginning to shake from the radio’s weight. Neelix’ face was showing evidence of his effort as well. Tuvok, watching them, came over and slid his hands underneath the apparatus.

With a sigh, Neelix let go and rubbed his hands. “Thanks, Mister Vulcan. I’ll only need a minute.”

“Logic suggests we should share the burden.”

In response, Seven reached over with her free hand, but Chakotay shook his head. “I’m fine. Is there any change to the vibration?”

She frowned briefly as she concentrated. “I am not able to perceive a change. But it’s possible that it is too subtle for me to recognize it using this rather crude manner.”

“We’ll keep trying.”

Several minutes later, there was still no change except that the hum had become softer.

“The power cell is limited,” observed Tuvok, who had relinquished his burden back to Neelix. “We have no way of telling how fast we are drawing from it.”

It was taking almost all of Chakotay’s effort to keep his hands from shaking. “Seven?” he asked.

“I still do not detect a difference.”

“All right, then. We won’t run the power cell completely down.” He disconnected the wire with a flick, and the apparatus fell silent. Neelix and he gave identical sighs of relief after they lowered it to the floor. “Any other ideas?”

They looked at each other, but no one spoke. Chakotay tried not to admit that an edge of despair was forming in his mind. Would they be found? Could they be?


Tuvok frowned. They’d been brainstorming new solutions for approximately fifty-six minutes if he included the periods of silence when nobody on the away team could think of something new. It was imperative that they develop a means of escape, however. If nothing else, the food supply in these abandoned caverns must be finite, and he had no intention of starving to death.

Unfortunately, that was a distinct possibility, particularly if Voyager couldn’t find a source of dilithium crystals soon.

“Perhaps,” he said into the most recent spate of quiet, “we should wait for our captors to return and determine their method for entering and exiting this holding cell.”

“But they might not ever come back!” retorted Neelix, and Tuvok suppressed a grimace at the Talaxian’s vociferous emotionalism. “It’s been at least six hours, and they haven’t come to check on us yet.”

“The day here is longer than a day on Earth,” he countered. “It is possible that, by the aliens’ standards, an appropriate interval simply has not yet passed.”

“At the same time, it’s logical to think they’d know about when we would wake up.”

“Not necessarily.”

“Oh? How do you figure that?”

But he didn’t respond. He had realized that the faint tapping sound he’d identified some three point eight minutes ago was getting louder, and had taken on a rhythm similar to, but not quite the same as, human or Vulcan footsteps.

“Mr. Neelix,” he said, “this argument is pointless. It may also be moot very soon.”

Chakotay joined him, peering out the opening that Tuvok stood near. “Do you hear something?”

“Yes.” He lapsed into silence again, this time to concentrate. “The cadence is similar to footsteps, but there are some differences—”

“Perhaps it’s the way the aliens walk.” The first officer gestured for the rest of the crew to sweep away the evidence of their earlier attempts to escape. “Look sharp.”

They hastily began working.

Tap-tap. Tap. Tap-tap-tap. Tap. Tap. Tap-tap.

The slow speed at which the aliens approach did not match what scant data Tuvok had about their appearance. At the same time, he reflected, the pattern could also be indicative of the possibility he’d first heard them from some distance off. As far as he could tell, the crystalline walls extended for some distance.

Beside him, Chakotay straightened suddenly. “You’re right. Not quite footsteps. I think that’s someone walking with a cane.”

“A cane?” He was Vulcan; he would not allow his hopes to rise. But it was unlikely that the aliens, if still present, would be making use of such items.

“Yes.” From the other man’s demeanor, Tuvok understood he wasn’t the only one who was thinking about someone who would be using a cane.

Although he was aware that barely an additional minute passed, it still seemed like an interminable time before the approaching persons came around a corner into view. Chakotay pressed himself against the opening. “Captain! It is you!”

“Finally.” She stopped, face betraying exhaustion, and leaned heavily on her cane. “The schematics didn’t tell us how far down this place was.”

“Schematics?” asked Tuvok.

“Yes. They were stored in the security room’s database.”

“How were you able to access them?”

She hefted a tricorder. “The translation matrix finally locked on to those words on the wall. They were instructions for bypassing the security systems.”

“Did the information in the database include the method for releasing the occupants of these holding cells?”

“Yeah,” said Lieutenant Kim, who had accompanied the captain. He finished tapping a series of commands into his own tricorder. “It’ll take me just a minute to find them—whoa. Wow.”

“Lieutenant?” asked the captain.

He wordlessly indicated the tricorder readout, and upon seeing it, her eyes widened.

“This wall,” she said, voice not quite even, “is made out of dilithium. Pure dilithium.”


“I think I can use it,” said B’Elanna as she examined the now-shattered remains of the holding cell wall. “The lattice structure is normal. But I’d like to take a few samples up and test them before we spend too much effort getting all this out of here.”

“Agreed,” answered Kathryn, and the chief engineer began collecting them.

The current theory was that the radiation and upheaval from the nova had affected the surface too greatly for any of the dilithium in the crust to be useful. But here, only slightly above the planet’s Mohorovičić discontinuity, they’d finally gotten deep enough that the rock had stopped the effects.

She stood in awe of the planet’s long-dead civilization. Creating a livable space so deep within the crust was quite the feat of engineering; Earth’s own Moho was uninhabitable for humans without full-time refrigeration and stabilizing force fields.

Of course, this planet’s discontinuity was located much higher than Earth’s.

Chakotay joined her. “I’m having the team take archaeological scans. These people were fascinating; it seems the majority of their technology was based on the use of crystalline structures. That could explain why they were able to do this.” He gestured to the walls around them.

“We certainly have a lot to learn from them,” she answered. “If B’Elanna is able to adapt the dilithium, it’ll take a few days to mine enough for our supplies. That’s enough time to do some studying.”

“Randleman would have been perfect for that,” he replied quietly. “I’ll find his notes and bring down some people from both science and engineering.”

“Good,” she answered. “I’ll be joining them.”

He sighed audibly. “You should know that I’ve already spoken with Tom.”

Kathryn frowned. “Don’t start, Commander.”

“I’d be remiss if I didn’t. How long did it take you to get down here from the surface?”

She shook her head. “It’s not relevant. We were running a search; that always takes more time than going straight to a known location.”

He met her eyes. “How much longer?”

But I’m the captain, and that’s an order, she almost said. It was, she realized, a defensive reaction. Instead of saying anything at all, she broke eye contact and began studying the tricorder readings again.

“I’m glad you’re the one who found the dilithium,” he said, and she blinked at the apparent change of subject. “It’s only fair, considering what it has taken from you.”

Kathryn looked back up.

“It cost you part of the use of your legs, and Randleman’s family will deserve whatever answers we find in the survey. Plus, I’m not insensitive to the fact that we’d have been trapped much longer if you hadn’t come down.” He sighed again. “That said, Captain, you know as well as I do what could have happened if you’d run into any more trouble.”

She returned the sigh. “I suppose you’re right.”

Chakotay met and held her gaze again. “There’s no shame in admitting you have restrictions. Everyone does, including me.”

She remembered Numinda Claari’s words. Acceptance is a far healthier reaction than a futile fight against the limits of time and fate. That only results in bitterness and regret.

It seemed this planet had other lessons for her as well.

“All right,” she said quietly, giving in. “But that means I’m asking you to help me get back up to the beam-out point.”

He chuckled and held out an arm. She took it, realizing that things felt almost normal again. Maybe the incident in the briefing room had been just an aberration.

Or, she reflected, thinking of the long-dead alien’s conclusions, maybe it was another message.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.